All articles

AI visibility case study: Bati Profit, 5 stars, unseen

In short. An AI visibility case study from real life: Bati Profit, a renovation company in Nice, is rated 5.0 with 31 reviews on Google. Yet across about 200 customer questions put to six AI assistants with web search, it was named once. When AI talked about it, 9 of 82 facts were wrong. This study, published with the company’s consent, shows what we measured and what a small business can take from it.

Illustration of a bright renovation site in Nice, with tools near a window open onto the sea.
Illustration. The figures in this article come from a real measurement; the image is a drawn scene.

We often publish general advice on AI visibility. Here we show a real, named case. Bati Profit is a Castel Studio client and agreed to the publication of its name and results. Facts about the company come from public register data, as shown on Societe.com; general explanations come from documentation by Google, OpenAI and Perplexity. All sources were checked on 3 November 2026.

Who is Bati Profit?

According to its Societe.com record, which reproduces public register data, BATI PROFIT is an active company, registered with INSEE on 8 December 2023, with its head office in Nice. Its declared activity falls under general masonry and structural work. On its website, the company presents construction, renovation, interior and exterior work, and turnkey projects on the Côte d’Azur.

On Google, as of 3 November 2026, its profile shows a 5.0 rating with 31 reviews. That is a good signal for Google Maps. The starting question was simple: when a customer asks an AI assistant who to call for work in Nice, is Bati Profit part of the answer?

Why publish a named case rather than an anonymous one? Because it can be checked. The register entry is public, the Google profile is public, and anyone can put similar questions to the same assistants. An anonymous example asks the reader to trust us; a named one lets them verify part of it themselves.

How was it measured?

We wrote questions the way real customers ask them, without the company name: type of work, town, practical constraints. The questions were phrased as a homeowner planning work would put them: renovating a bathroom, redoing a façade, finding a company for a turnkey project in a Côte d’Azur town. We put them to six AI assistants, with web search on, using accounts without personal history. For each answer we noted whether Bati Profit was named, whether it was recommended, and whether another company was named instead.

We kept those answers separate from answers “from memory”, given by models without web search. Finally, we collected every fact the assistants gave about the company when its name was given, and compared them with the official register and the company’s website.

What are the results?

AI assistant (with web search) Bati Profit named Another company named
ChatGPT 1 of 50 89% of answers
Perplexity 0 of 50 70%
Gemini 0 of 50 63%
Claude 0 of 22 59%
Microsoft Copilot 0 of 10 (incomplete sample) 100%
Mistral Le Chat 0 of 21 (incomplete sample) 81%

In the one answer where ChatGPT named Bati Profit, it also recommended it. In all the others, the customer’s question did get an answer with company names, just not Bati Profit’s. That is the key point for a business owner. AI does not refuse to answer for lack of information; it answers with the businesses it finds most easily.

Without web search, no model named Bati Profit, across more than 4,000 answers. That is not surprising for a company created at the end of 2023: models answering from memory mostly know what was widely published before their training.

The businesses named instead are other renovation companies in the area. We do not publish their names: this study is about Bati Profit, not its competitors.

What do AI assistants say about Bati Profit?

When given the company’s name, the assistants provided information about it. Of 82 facts checked, 73 were correct and 9 wrong (11%). The errors we found:

  • Incorrect addresses, including several Nice addresses that are not the company’s, and a location in Paris.
  • Website names that do not belong to it, built from its name with another extension or a hyphen.
  • A wrong founding year, between 2012 and 2015, while the company was registered with INSEE on 8 December 2023.

For a customer, these errors have a concrete cost: a wrong website or address, and the contact never happens.

These errors do not come from nowhere. An assistant that finds no clear information sometimes fills the gap with plausible details: an address in the right town, a logical website name, a date that seems consistent. The result looks credible, which makes it all the more misleading for the customer.

A paper checklist of facts about a company, some ticked as correct, others crossed out.
Illustration of the fact check. The errors described in the article come from the real measurement.

Why does a well-rated business stay invisible to AI?

We do not know how the assistants work internally. But several public facts help explain the gap.

  • Google Maps and AI do not judge the same thing. Google explains that its local ranking rests on three factors: relevance of the profile, distance and prominence, to which the number of reviews and positive ratings contribute. A very good Google profile serves that ranking first.
  • AI assistants search with their own crawlers. OpenAI states that its OAI-SearchBot crawler is used to surface websites in ChatGPT’s search results. Perplexity describes PerplexityBot in the same way. What these crawlers find, and on which pages, matters as much as the Google profile.
  • A young business leaves few traces online. Created at the end of 2023, Bati Profit has fewer articles, directory listings and mentions than companies established for ten years. Assistants more readily name businesses about which they find plenty of consistent information.
  • Scattered information produces errors. When several websites, profiles and directories describe the business differently, the assistant mixes the sources.

What lessons for a small business?

  1. A good reputation does not pass to AI by itself. Google reviews are valuable, but they are not enough to be named by an assistant.
  2. Measure before you act. Without reference questions asked on a fixed date, you cannot tell whether a change had any effect.
  3. Check what AI says about you. A wrong address or website diverts customers who had actually found you.
  4. The same information everywhere. Identical name, address, phone, website, services and service area on your website, your Google profile and directories.
  5. Measure again with the same questions. It is the only way to compare before and after.

For Bati Profit, the next step is to correct and complete the published information, then repeat the measurement with the same questions.

What are the limits of this study?

  • It is a snapshot. The figures date from 3 November 2026; assistants’ answers change over time.
  • The sample is limited. At most 50 questions per assistant, fewer for Copilot and Le Chat.
  • One case. These results do not automatically apply to another business, trade or town.
  • Accounts and settings matter. We used accounts without personal history; answers given to a regular user with memory and location turned on may differ.
  • No conclusion about sales. We measure AI assistants’ answers, not lost customers.

How does Castel Studio carry out this kind of study?

This measurement is part of our AI visibility offer. It starts with a free express check; the full Google and AI visibility audit, from 1,200 €, adds 3 to 5 direct competitors, an action plan and a repeat measurement after the agreed changes. For the basics, read our guide to AI visibility, and for your core business information, our guide to setting up a Google Business Profile.

Tell us your business name, your town and three questions your customers ask. We reply in writing within 48 hours, including to tell you if AI already names you correctly.

Questions

Why is a business with good Google reviews not named by AI?

Google's local ranking is based on relevance, distance and prominence of the profile. AI assistants with web search use their own crawlers and the pages they find. A young business with little presence beyond its Google profile can therefore be well rated and still be missing from AI answers.

How often did AI assistants name Bati Profit?

As of 3 November 2026, ChatGPT with web search named it once in 50 customer questions. Perplexity and Gemini 0 times in 50, Claude 0 in 22, Copilot 0 in 10 and Le Chat 0 in 21, the last two on incomplete samples. Without web search, from memory, no model named it.

What mistakes does AI make about a business?

Of 82 facts checked, 9 were wrong: incorrect addresses, including one in Paris, website names that do not belong to the company, and a founding year between 2012 and 2015, while the register shows December 2023.

Is this case study published with the company's consent?

Yes. Bati Profit, a Castel Studio client, agreed to the publication of its name and the measurement results. The names of the businesses named instead of it are not published.

How do I know if my business is in the same situation?

Ask two or three AI assistants with web search about ten customer questions without your name, then check what they say about you. At Castel Studio, the express check is free and the full audit starts at 1,200 €.

Contact

One person reads this inbox — the same person who builds what you order.

Describe your task

Tell us what you have and what result you need — even a single small task. No brief required: within 48 hours you get a plan and a price in writing, a question, or an honest “not a fit”.

Include the situation, files or links, deadline, language, privacy limits and budget boundary if you have one.

File (optional)
No file chosen

A brief, a photo, a spreadsheet — whatever explains the task faster than words. Up to 8 MB, stored with our hosting provider. Please don't send sensitive personal or medical documents through the site.

Sending creates no order and no payment. We reply within 48 hours. Prefer email? contact@castel.studio

Talk to us

Prefer a call or a messenger? Write or call — the studio's founder answers.

Connect on LinkedIn

Prefer a freelance platform?

Order the same work there, with the platform's secure payment.

A one-person AI studio in Nice. Whoever answers your message is the one who does the work — no account managers in between. Files are processed on our own machine, not in someone else's cloud.

Nice 06100, France · Open in maps →

SIREN 103 115 705

Describe your task