All articles

Cookie banner requirements: what the CNIL expects

In short. Cookie banner requirements in France: the CNIL, the data protection authority, says cookies that are not strictly needed require consent that is free, specific, informed and unambiguous, given by a positive action before any such cookie is placed. Refusing must be as easy as accepting, and withdrawing as easy as giving. Our privacy check starts from 290 € and tests your site as a visitor sees it; it is a technical review, not legal advice.

A glass jar of plain round biscuits with a blank paper label and a small brass scale on a marble counter in a bakery in Nice, a window onto pastel facades behind
A cookie jar with a clear label: say what is inside, and let the visitor decide before anything is taken.

Owners often ask whether their cookie banner is lawful, and the honest answer starts with what is actually set on the page. This guide reads three published pages of the CNIL, the French data protection authority, and turns them into a table, a short list of rules and a five-minute check you can do yourself. It explains the rules in plain language and it is not legal advice. The pages we read date from 2020 and 2021, so check the CNIL site for later changes before you rely on a detail.

Those that are not strictly necessary for something the visitor asked for. The CNIL’s page on what the law says gives examples on both sides, and we have put them in one table.

Tracker Consent needed?
Remembers your choice about trackers No, exempt
Authentication, including limiting robotic access attempts No, exempt
Shopping cart or billing No, exempt
Interface personalisation such as language, if intrinsic and expected No, exempt
Load balancing No, exempt
Some audience measurement meeting specific conditions No, exempt if the conditions are met
Personalised advertising Yes
Social network cookies, such as those from share buttons Yes
Any cookie not strictly necessary for the requested service Yes, in general

The last line is the one that decides most cases. If you cannot explain why a tracker is needed for a service the visitor asked for, assume it needs consent. A product label such as “privacy-friendly analytics” does not make a tracker exempt: the conditions must actually be met.

It must be free, specific, informed and unambiguous, given through a positive action. The same CNIL page adds practical rules. Consent must be obtained before any cookie is placed or read. It must be requested again when a new purpose requiring consent is added. Accepting general terms of use is not a valid method, so a line saying that browsing means acceptance does not work. And the visitor must be able to withdraw consent at any time as easily as they gave it.

Information must be clear, visible, prominent and complete, written in simple terms, and it must state the purposes and the identity of those responsible. Two levels of information are acceptable: a first level that briefly describes each purpose, and a second that gives more detail and the list of controllers.

Must refusing be as easy as accepting?

Yes, and this is the rule most banners fail. The CNIL’s 2021 page on refusing cookies reports that about twenty organisations received formal notices on 18 May 2021 over this point, and that all of them, including large digital companies, had complied about a month later. The authority also said that further corrective measures would follow against anyone who did not comply.

The CNIL’s guidelines and recommendation page recommends a “refuse all” button in addition to the “accept all” button. Our reading, which is not the CNIL’s wording, is that the first screen should offer a refuse button at the same level as accept. A refuse option hidden behind a “settings” link while accept sits on the first screen is hard to square with a rule that says refusing must be as simple as accepting.

Two identical brass doorbells side by side on a pastel wall in old Nice, one with a green enamel ring and one with a blue enamel ring, both with blank name plates
Two buttons of the same size and the same height: opening the door and closing it should take the same effort.

How long should a refusal be remembered?

We cannot give a figure, because the pages we read do not give one. The CNIL’s guidelines page only suggests keeping the visitor’s refusal for a period so that the visitor is not asked at every visit. The six-month period mentioned there is the deadline given to organisations to comply, not a retention period for a choice. Ask your adviser for the current recommendation and set the period in your banner tool.

How can you check your own banner in five minutes?

Test the site the way a first-time visitor sees it, before clicking anything. This is a technical self-check and not a legal opinion.

  • Open the site in a private window, so that no earlier choice is stored.
  • Before clicking anything on the banner, open the browser’s developer tools and look at the cookies and the network requests. If advertising or statistics tools are already contacting other providers, consent was not waited for.
  • Read the first screen of the banner: is there a refuse option as visible as accept?
  • Click refuse, reload the page and check again that nothing non-exempt is set.
  • Find the place where a visitor can change their mind, and count the clicks to withdraw.
  • Test an embedded video or map: does it load another provider’s code before consent?

A banner can look reassuring while a video or statistics tool is already contacting another provider, which is why this check looks at what happens, not at what the banner says.

What does our privacy check include and cost?

Our privacy check starts from 290 € once. It covers one supported site and language, up to 10 public URLs, one banner, one contact form and two types of external embed, with one correction round. You receive the technical findings, agreed minor fixes, a log of repeat tests and drafts of the privacy texts for review by your adviser. The usual duration is five to seven working days after we have access and your approvals.

It does not include paid licences, custom development, extra pages, languages, forms or monitoring. We do not provide legal advice or data protection officer work, and we do not keep your processing register. A technical check is not a certificate that your whole business complies with GDPR. A site without cookies may still handle personal data through forms or server logs.

When can you leave the banner alone?

When the site sets only exempt trackers and you can say which. A small site with a contact form, no statistics, no embedded videos and no advertising may have little to consent to. Even then, tell visitors what you do with the data they send. If you are unsure, test first rather than guess. Every extra tool you add later, a statistics script, a video, an advertising tag, can change the answer, so repeat the check whenever you add one.

If you plan advertising, the cost of a banner that works properly sits in the same budget as the campaign. See what Google Ads costs and what Facebook ads cost, and for the site itself what a website costs.

What should you prepare for a privacy check?

Bring a short list:

  • The address of the site and who can change its settings.
  • The list of tools you added: statistics, chat, video, maps, advertising tags, forms.
  • The banner tool you use, if any, and who set it up.
  • Your current privacy text, if you have one.
  • The name of your adviser, if you have one, for the text review.

How does Castel Studio run the check?

We open the site as a first-time visitor, record what is set and contacted before and after each choice, fix the settings we can change safely after your approval and give you a plain-language list of what remains. We say plainly what we observed and what we did not test.

Send us your site address and the tools you use. We reply in writing within 48 hours.

Questions

Does every website need a cookie banner?

No. According to the CNIL, some trackers are exempt from consent, for example those that store your choice about trackers, authentication, shopping cart, interface language and some audience measurement that meets specific conditions. A site that sets only exempt trackers does not need a consent banner for them, though it must still inform visitors.

Must a visitor be able to refuse as easily as accept?

Yes. The CNIL states that refusing must be as easy as accepting, with the same degree of simplicity, and that withdrawing consent must be as easy as giving it. It recommends a button to refuse everything next to the button to accept everything.

Is it enough to say that by continuing to browse you accept cookies?

No. The CNIL says valid consent requires a clear positive action, and that accepting general terms of use is not a valid method. Consent must also be obtained before any non-exempt cookie is placed or read.

Can Castel Studio check my site?

Yes. Our privacy check starts from 290 € once, for one site and language, up to 10 public URLs, one banner, one contact form and two types of external embed, with one correction round. It is a technical review, not legal advice.

Contact

One person reads this inbox — the same person who builds what you order.

Describe your task

Tell us what you have and what result you need — even a single small task. No brief required: within 48 hours you get a plan and a price in writing, a question, or an honest “not a fit”.

Include the situation, files or links, deadline, language, privacy limits and budget boundary if you have one.

File (optional)
No file chosen

A brief, a photo, a spreadsheet — whatever explains the task faster than words. Up to 8 MB, stored with our hosting provider. Please don't send sensitive personal or medical documents through the site.

Sending creates no order and no payment. We reply within 48 hours. Prefer email? contact@castel.studio

Talk to us

Prefer a call or a messenger? Write or call — the studio's founder answers.

Connect on LinkedIn

Prefer a freelance platform?

Order the same work there, with the platform's secure payment.

A one-person AI studio in Nice. Whoever answers your message is the one who does the work — no account managers in between. Files are processed on our own machine, not in someone else's cloud.

Nice 06100, France · Open in maps →

SIREN 103 115 705

Describe your task